Noodlers Brown ranks about 65% in my book.
Overview:
Noodlers brown originally got me interested for two reasons:
1) It looked like it shaded really well.
2) It looked like the perfect shade of brown.
Overall I am a little bit disappointed in this ink. Not completely, but it certainly is not exactly what I thought it'd be. It has some major (t0 me at least) downfalls, that I'l hit on in this review.
The good:
- It is a nice shade of brown. Not perfect, but better than most.
- It's a Noodlers ink, so it's not expensive to buy.
The Bad:
- It has some major bleed-through issues. Wait till you see the photos below...
- Color is too dark for me. Sometimes it looks black. It's the right shade of brown, but it needs a touch more light to it.
- Dry time is a bit slow.
All in all, it's a decent ink, but I'd like to find something to replace it. I only bought a sample, in my hunt for the perfect brown. This is not the perfect brown. It's a good one, and some aspects are real close, but it's not there.
Onto the review!
Ink Review: Noodlers Brown
Pen and nib: Lamy 2000 - B nib
Color: Dark Brown
Dry time: 15-20 seconds. Not bad for such a wet pen.
Smear when dry: A tiny bit...
Shading: Low/moderate. I think a less wet pen would actually shade better.
Lubrication: Good.
Bleed-through: Quite a bit actually. I wish it wasn't so...
Feathering: A very small amount.
Here's the scan. I think this one's pretty accurate.
Here is a shot of that bleed-through. Yikes! You'll notice that the bleed-through looks red-ish. It is in person too. It seems that the red-hue of the ink is separating, and bleeding through the paper.
Another shot of the swab...
Overall:
This is an okay ink, but it's poor behavior makes it a no go for me. Again, if these small problems were fixed, this could be a real winner. But until then (or if ever), I will be searching for another brown.
Anybody here got a brown to recommend? Waterman Havana Brown is next on my list to try, thanks to Peninkcillin. :)
Anyone else ever tried this ink before? Did you get the same impression that I got? I'm wondering if it's just my pen and nib combo. I'll try it in my fine nibbed VP, and see what happens.
I hope you enjoyed the review. As always, feel free to leave me a comment and let me know what you think. If you've never left a comment before, now's your chance. :)
Until Wednesday then!
Regards,
Tyler Dahl
No comments:
Post a Comment